top of page
Search

How to Create a Pickup Experience That Keeps Customers Coming Back | Episode 91



Your bread is amazing. But do you know what your customers really remember? How they felt picking it up.


Your pickup experience isn’t just a transaction—it’s a chance to show your customers they’re valued. And you don’t need a fancy storefront to do it. Even if you’re running pickups from your front porch, you can create a warm, professional, memorable experience that keeps people coming back week after week.


Here’s how to make your pickup process clear, welcoming, and something people talk about—in the best way.


Why Your Pickup Experience Matters

Think about the best small business experience you’ve ever had. Chances are, it wasn’t about fancy packaging or slick branding.

It was about how you felt. Seen. Welcome. Valued.

When your customers have a great experience, they’re more likely to:

  • Come back again.

  • Tell their friends about you.

  • Treat your business with respect.


A great pickup experience builds trust and credibility—even without a storefront.


1. Make Your Instructions Crystal Clear

Confusion is the enemy of customer loyalty.

Ask yourself: Could a first-time customer figure out exactly where to go and what to do without asking you?

Here’s the critical info you should share automatically when someone orders:

  • Exact pickup address (often sent automatically through apps like Simply Bread or Hot Plate).

  • Pickup window or specific time.

  • Clear description of your house or pickup location (for example, “first on the left with the blue porch”).

  • Landmark or directions if your location is tricky to find.

  • What to expect when they arrive—like a labeled bag on a porch table.

  • Whether they need to knock or can grab and go.

Example message:

“Thank you for your order! Pickup is Saturday 8–10 a.m. at 123 Main Street. Look for the table on the porch with a Bluebird Bread Co. sign. Your name will be on your bag. No need to knock—just grab and go. Feel free to knock if you have questions.”


The easier and clearer you make it, the more confident (and happy) your customers will be.


2. Create a Welcoming Setup

Your setup doesn’t have to be fancy. But it should feel intentional, clear, and aligned with the quality of your bread.

Ideas to make it feel warm and professional:

  • A clear, friendly sign with your bakery name (vinyl sign, chalkboard, or easel).

  • Directional signage if you have a long driveway or confusing layout.

  • Baskets, crates, or shelves to organize bags (grouped by time slot or name).

  • A cloth tablecloth over a folding table instead of plastic.

  • A printed order list for customers to double-check if needed.

  • A cooler for items that need to stay chilled (clearly labeled so nothing is missed).

  • A small framed sign or chalkboard with a warm thank-you message.


Example greeting:

“Thanks for supporting our small business! — Caroline & Family”

It doesn’t need to be over-the-top. Just thoughtful, clear, and welcoming.


3. Prepare for Hiccups with Grace

Stuff happens. Orders get forgotten. Customers run late. Loaves burn.

Being prepared—and handling it kindly—makes all the difference.

For late pickups: Have a friendly follow-up ready to go. Example:

“Hi! Friendly reminder your order is ready for pickup until 8 p.m. Let me know when you’re heading over!”

For wrong bag pickups: Prevent confusion with large, clear name labels on bags. Consider snapping a photo of the setup so you can double-check if needed.

For weather issues:

  • Use a canopy or porch cover for rain.

  • Move pickup indoors if needed, but have clear signage telling people to knock.

For your own mix-ups: Own it quickly and sincerely. Example:

“I’m so sorry—your cookie box didn’t make it into your bag. I can refund it or you can swing by to grab it later. Let me know what you’d prefer.”


Customers aren’t expecting perfection. But they will remember how you respond.


4. Add Small Moments of Joy

This is the fun part. It doesn’t have to be big or expensive—just thoughtful.

Ideas for delighting your customers:

  • Include a free cookie, especially for first orders or regulars.

  • Offer half-size sample cookies to introduce new flavors.

  • Add seasonal flowers or herbs to your table.

  • Write a cute or heartfelt greeting on your chalkboard.

  • Leave stickers for kids to grab.

  • Use a note like “It’s a good day for good bread.”

  • These touches make your brand memorable. They show customers they’re valued and appreciated.


5. Be Ready for Anything

Finally, plan ahead for the inevitable.

  • Have template texts ready for reminders or apologies.

  • Label every bag clearly.

  • Have a system for tracking orders.

  • Consider using a Ring camera or taking a quick setup photo for reference.


Little details go a long way.


Recap: Four Ways to Wow with Your Pickup Experience

  1. Crystal-Clear Instructions – Eliminate confusion so customers know exactly where to go and what to do.

  2. Welcoming, Professional Setup – Use signs, baskets, tablecloths, and friendly messages to make them feel at home.

  3. Graceful Problem Solving – Be prepared for hiccups and handle them with professionalism and kindness.

  4. Small Moments of Joy – Surprise and delight with simple, thoughtful touches.

Your bread is why they buy. But the way you make them feel is why they come back.

Even if you’re selling from your porch, you can make your pickup experience something special. Intentional, warm, professional.


These small steps don’t take much extra time, but they can transform a simple pickup into an experience your customers love—and remember.


Links to things you might like!





 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page